Is Julian Edleman a Hall of Famer?

[Big Bear]

People trying to call Julian Edleman a hall of famer but lets not forget he tested positive 3 times for steroids prior to the season

If he gets in Barry Bonds should too.

[danshan11]

hell no forget the roids, he has not done enough career wise

[GzaTheGenius]

Cheater

[Snowball]

yes

[lakerboy]

No. He wouldn't even be mentioned if he didn't play the new England

[ikid2groove415]

Barry bonds was a all time great in baseball - won 3 mvp before roids-

[Big Bear]

No. He wouldn't even be mentioned if he didn't play the new England

But he DOES play for New England

you could say maybe the same thing about Jerry Rice

he had Joe Montana and Steve Young

what if Cam Newton was his QB or Mark Sanchez???

he would have never been great

[ikid2groove415]

But he DOES play for New England

you could say maybe the same thing about Jerry Rice

he had Joe Montana and Steve Young

what if Cam Newton was his QB or Mark Sanchez???

he would have never been great

Just stop - embarrassing

[lakerboy]

But he DOES play for New England

you could say maybe the same thing about Jerry Rice

he had Joe Montana and Steve Young

what if Cam Newton was his QB or Mark Sanchez???

he would have never been great

WOW. Jerry Rice is the greatest football player ever bro. Delete this post.

[Big Bear]

Just stop - embarrassing

I’m serious man

a WR is only as good as his QB

a pitcher is only as good as his catcher.

team sport.

Imagine playing WR with a guy like Cam throwing you the ball 10 feet over your head

You jump up to catch it and get layed the fukk out

or you just barely get a hand on it and its tipped up for an INT

[TheMoneyShot]

Hall of Fame? You kidding me? No.

[MrSink]

he is not

[DOM_Toretto]

2nd most playoff yards & catches all time behind only Rice, 3-1 in SBs, SB MVP

& roids

still helluva resume

[ikid2groove415]

I’m kinda lost when you said pitchers only as good as there catchers ....couldn’t be way off - now yes every WR needs a decent QB- but the great WR can create separation and run there routes 2 perfection like Jerry rice - I believe Brady had his best year with randy moss? A Real HOF WR- not a slot guy

[SharpAngles]

First ballot douchebag Hall of Fame

[Grits n' Gravy]

No. Another 4-5 seasons of very good production and postseason catches might get him in the conversation but it is highly unlikely.

[Hman]

Surely Wes Weller would get in before he would.

I mean his career isn't over yet so who knows

[Hman]

Everyone assuming he's still in PED's.

Stereotyping?

The guy is smart & knows how to get open.

[jjgold]

Brady makes everyone a hall of famer

[JIBBBY]

No one could stay with and guard him in the Superbowl that's all I know.. Without that guy the Patriots don't win probably. http://www.nfl.com/news/story/0ap300...-hall-of-famer

[PromiseLand]

Is this a joke? He only has 499 receptions, 5390 yards, and 30 TDs for his career. Remember how long it took Cris Carter to get in? He had over 1100 receptions, 13,899 yards, and 130 TDs. Edelman isn't even on the HOF radar.

[ikid2groove415]

Imagine all the time he used PED and didn’t get caught? People are so naive

[swordsandtequila]

You make more by thread or post count Bear?

[Matt17]

No.

[cincinnatikid513]

if your going to put philip rivers in the hall of fame might as well edells

[ikid2groove415]

if your going to put philip rivers in the hall of fame might as well edells

Rivers did everything but win the super bowl - he’s got numbers 2 go into canton - Edelman doesn’t have the numbers - case closed

[rm18]

He has 30 TDs in 10 seasons

Carl Pickens had 29 in 2 seasons.

[ikid2groove415]

He has 30 TDs in 10 seasons

Carl Pickens had 29 in 2 seasons.

He’s tough and clutch in big games -

[rm18]

I’m serious man

a WR is only as good as his QB

a pitcher is only as good as his catcher.

team sport.

Imagine playing WR with a guy like Cam throwing you the ball 10 feet over your head

You jump up to catch it and get layed the fukk out

or you just barely get a hand on it and its tipped up for an INT

I great WR can make an average QB great Moss made Cunningham and Culpepper superstars, but he couldnt help a guy like Spergon Wynn who was so bad.

[MinnesotaFats]

Drew Pearson
Mark Duper
Mark Clayton
Henry Ellard
Anthony Carter
Gary Clark

No way Edelman getting in before some of this list

I'm down on A Gates at TE too until Steve Jordan gets serious considerations

[bonzaii]

Barry bonds was a all time great in baseball - won 3 mvp before roids-

Yet he cheated and is about to get in while Pete Rose still isn't in the hall. Barry Bonds and all cheaters should be banned permanently. Hall of a fame is a joke.

[ikid2groove415]

Yet he cheated and is about to get in while Pete Rose still isn't in the hall. Barry Bonds and all cheaters should be banned permanently. Hall of a fame is a joke.

Rose bet against his own team in gambling - don’t be naive and think he didn’t - everyone was juice up during the roid era - pitchers/hitters - bonds was already a HOF before he did Roids

[bonzaii]

Who cares if he did. Is he a scumbag? Yes, but that shouldn't matter. That has nothing to do with someone's overall stats which show he should be a clear hall of famer. He didn't use something which is illegal to gain an edge to improve his performance.

[Hman]

Barry bonds was a all time great in baseball - won 3 mvp before roids-

He started taking them the day he became an MLB'er

Just took a while before they became noticeable

[ikid2groove415]

Who cares if he did. Is he a scumbag? Yes, but that shouldn't matter. That has nothing to do with someone's overall stats which show he should be a clear hall of famer. He didn't use something which is illegal to gain an edge to improve his performance.

Once again bonds is a HOF before Roids - -